That's what the bears were asking by the end of the day. After getting run over by the car, and then the bus and then more cars, the shorts didn't exactly feel the love today. The strong rally brought out the bullish analysts slapping themselves on the back about what a wonderful buying opportunity it was and that here we go, welcome to the start of the year-end rally to new all-time highs. It seems to me we've heard that song before at each of the other sharp rallies in the past month and therefore we certainly need to consider those predictions as a possibility but the bulls need to keep this going in order to turn it into a probability.
Right now we've got ourselves another strong bear-market rally--these are typically very sharp rallies that flame out quickly. They spike out the short players, suck in the hopeful bulls and then the buying stops as suddenly as it started. To say we have something different this time is entirely too early. I've been expecting a strong bounce for the past few days as SPX came down to support (its long term uptrend line from March 2003) and was showing bullish divergences at its new lows over the past week. It was a very good setup to try the long side. For those who were short coming into today it would have been a good time to cover at support and wait for the break down. Today's rally has clearly put off until tomorrow, or next week or next month, a break of long term support (which I'll review on its charts).
Just as the market dropped to solid support on the SPX yesterday it rallied to what could be solid resistance for the DOW. After breaking its longer term uptrend line from July 2006 earlier this month, today's rally took the DOW right back up to it, practically to the penny at 13325. I had recommended a short play (in the Market Monitor) on the DOW based on that resistance and it's a good setup to consider tomorrow if it continues to hold as resistance. I'll also review that in tonight's charts.
So it was an exciting day and in actuality it's been an exciting month as far as big moves in the market go. From the emails I've received I would say it's probably been more frustrating than exciting for traders and that's because of the volatility and market turns coming out of left field. The market reversals have been hard and swift and unless you're very quick on the trading trigger it's been a market that has been whacking both sides unmercifully. Believe me when I say you're not alone if you've been struggling to trade this market. The trick has been, and will likely continue to be, to take chunks out of the middle of a move and be happy with that. Those who have been holding on for bigger moves find themselves typically giving it all back.
While it may be hard to exit a trade (hopefully with a profit) only to watch the move continue without you, it's very important in times like these to feel good about trading profitably and recognize you probably won't catch the entire move. If you have good entries with good risk management (try for at least 2:1 if not 3:1 reward:risk ratio) and then use a trailing stop (moving averages, previous high/low, trend lines, etc.) or profit targets then understand you're trading with good discipline and forget about what the market does once you exit the trade. Be thankful for trading well and taking money out of the market instead of resentful about what you didn't get. In fact there's a life lesson in there don't you think?
A reason given for today's monster rally was some Fed-speak about maybe the Fed will be forced to consider another rate cut, maybe, possibly, could happen, might not happen, but then again... In reality the market was ready to rally and the news didn't matter. It's just analysts looking for a reason. How about "the market was oversold and some buy programs (which started during the overnight session) spiked the shorts out of the market and then the rally fed on itself." Nah, then they wouldn't be able to make the big bucks declaring nonsensical reasons for why the market does what it does. And if it sells off tomorrow they'll say the market thinks the Fed is on hold again or maybe an economic slowdown really isn't good for the stock market. Efficient market? Hardly.
If the market truly rallied on hopes for another rate cut (vs. rallying more on short covering and bargain hunting) I would suggest that traders should be careful for what they wish for. Another rate cut by the Fed, especially in light of the rising inflation and sinking dollar (and all the associated unrest overseas from our trading partners), would indicate that the Fed sees significant risk of a slowing economy that outweighs the risk of rising inflation (we probably have both coming but that's a different discussion). One needs to ask if continuing to buy into a bull market would be the smartest thing to do in that case. In other words, why would the market rally if the economy is headed down the toilet to the extent the Fed would need to continue lowering interest rates?
There are many who still believe that the Fed lowering interest rates leads to a bull market. One look at 2000-2002 should quickly disabuse anyone of that idea (at least from a timing perspective) but of course a logical market is clearly an oxymoron. But beware--hoping for a Fed rate cut as a reason to rally the market would be one of the better bull traps. Just look at how well the three previous cuts in the discount rate have worked for the bulls (not very). To think it'll be different with a 4th rate cut is to ignore recent price action around the Fed's actions.
The other "positive" news was related to banks but in reality it's just another bottom call. The feeling is it can't get any worse (actually it can get a lot worse) and therefore it's a good time to buy the banks. They've been sold off hard the past month so to see them bounce hard today is very typical. I'll show a few charts on the banks to give an idea where we are in their price pattern. But the strong rally in the banks was very positive for both the SPX and the DOW. This gave the DOW its strongest rally of the year in percentage terms and only five points shy of its largest point advance of nearly 336 points on September 18th (the day the FOMC announced their rate cut).
As can be seen in the table at the top of this report, buying was extremely strong, at least as measured by up volume relative to down volume which ran better than 11:1. Advancing issues were better than 4:1 over declining issues. In fact it could be considered too strong--it looks more like what you see as a capitulation move rather than just a strong buying day. And in fact it was likely a lot of capitulation by the bears who covered short positions all day. This is exactly what causes bear market rallies and why it's dangerous to buy into them since they can turn on a dime with some hard selling. Whether or not we've got something different this time is entirely too early to tell.
One thing that I found odd, and highlighted in the table above, is the number of new 52-week lows being higher than the 52-week highs. Today started with a big gap up and rallied strong all day and yet new lows still outnumbered new highs by better than 2:1. This is not supportive a strong buying across the board, or even short covering in the beaten down stocks. Instead the weak stocks appear to have been sold even more. It's a warning flag at this point and something to keep an eye on as it's something we saw in the previous sharp one-day wonder rallies.
We will show you how you can make $2,000 in cash each month using your existing portfolio equity as collateral. This low-risk strategy works no matter which direction the market goes. Best of all, it is easy to implement and no previous experience with options is necessary.
Take a complimentary 30 day test drive. Click Here:
Today's economic news was certainly not bull-friendly but nor did it stop the rally. Today's reports were essentially ignored (for now) although the afternoon release of the Fed Beige Book, showing a slowdown in the economy, created another buying spree on hopes for the Fed rate cut. I know, it doesn't make any sense to me either.
Starting the day, before the economic reports were released, was a statement by Fed Vice-Chairman Donald Kohn, "Federal Reserve monetary policy must be nimble, pragmatic and flexible given uncertainties over how the renewed turmoil in financial markets will effect lending to consumers and businesses." He further stated "If the turmoil stems from banks worrying that interest rates will rise, the Fed should be able to address it."
There are lots of ways for the Fed to address the banks' need for capital but what the market heard was a Fed ready to cut rates further. The stronger message from the Fed heads lately is that they see more risk from inflation and don't see the need to make further cuts but one "maybe, perhaps, could happen" from Mr. Kohn and it was off to the races. Did he just trap the Fed into making another rate cut, something they didn't want to happen? One can only speculate how the stock market will react if they don't get their rate cut now.
The rest of today' reports follows:
Durable Goods Orders
Existing Home Sales
Fed's Beige Book
It did note that manufacturing has benefitted some from the weaker US dollar, as has the tourism business. I listened to a news report last night about the increase in the number of tourists coming over from Europe and taking bus trips into NY City not to sightsee but to shop. The bargains they're finding, because of the weaker dollar, apparently more than covers the cost of their airfare.
The report cited soft retail sales and pessimism about the holiday season as retailers see inventory piling up on their shelves. The troubles in the financial market, and the negative impact on the credit market, have caused problems for businesses in getting loans. The report did cite stronger signs in the nonfinancial sectors. Demand for legal services increased (and I suspect will continue to increase as the subprime and other poor lending practices, not to mention shareholder anger, causes a sharp increase in the lawsuits that will start flying).
With today's big rally, following yesterday's, let's see what the charts look like. First I want to review the 10-year yield since it has made a strong bounce the past two days, with the stock market, and could provide some clues as to what's next:
10-year Yield (TNX), Daily
The wave count for the decline in the 10-year yield would look best with another low following the current bounce. The bounce in the yield should stay below 4.1% (to stay inside the down-channel) and then drop to a new low with 3.7% being a good downside Fib target. So the question tonight is whether or not the yield will drop a little lower and what that could then mean for the stock market. Right now the stock market and yields are trading somewhat in synch and therefore this chart, if it drops lower from here, is saying the stock market could do the same thing. So watch the bond market.
DOW chart, Daily
The DOW rallied right up to its broken uptrend line from July 2006, which it broke below earlier this month. If price drops back then it's going to look like a classic test of support-turned-resistance and could give us a kiss goodbye here. As bullish as today was, the bulls need to keep it going otherwise it will have been just another bear market rally. This kind of setup I always recommend a short play since you can keep your stop relatively tight. It might not work but it's always worth a try.
While the DOW rallied a little higher than its 200-dma it's not uncommon to see it over and under throw that moving average. I noticed the NYSE stopped dead at its 100-dma today at 9806.
DOW chart, 60-min
The move up from Monday afternoon would look better with a slight pullback on Thursday and then another minor new high (in order to complete a nicer looking 5-wave move). But I've seen enough moves "missing" the 5th wave on shorter timeframe charts to know that I can't plan on seeing it. Therefore any strong selling tomorrow would be potentially more immediately bearish. Not only did the DOW slam into its broken uptrend line from July 2006 but it also stopped at the mid line of its down-channel from the October high.
SPX chart, Daily
SPX stopped right at its 38% retracement of the Oct-Nov decline. It's still shy of its 200-dma and the top of a parallel down-channel drawn off the downtrend line along the lows, both near 1483, and there's the "wall" at 1490, so there's a little more upside potential on this one. As shown with the dark red wave count there is the possibility we'll get a larger upward correction over the next few weeks (expect some more whipsaws and choppy price action if true). Obviously a drop back below Monday's low at 1406 would be bearish.
SPX chart, 60-min
Like the DOW I show the possibility for a small pullback tomorrow followed by another push higher to complete a 5-wave move up from Monday. That kind of move could get it up to resistance at 1490 and would be a good level to try the short side if it happens. A 5-wave move will be followed by a correction and therefore would make for a good trade. At today's high it may have completed a sharp 3-wave a-b-c correction and that's another reason to consider the short side (coinciding with the DOW's resistance at its broken uptrend line).
Nasdaq-100 (NDX) chart, Daily
The very choppy price action following the low on November 12th makes it look like this week's rally is wave-C of an A-B-C upward correction off the low on the 12th. If this is the correct interpretation then it's a setup for a great short play for what will be wave-3 to new lows, shown in dark red. The c-wave of an a-b-c correction is known as the sucker wave because it convinces traders that the previous trend (down in this case) is finished when in fact it is the completion of a correction. It's what makes the 3rd wave so strong as traders (bulls in this case) get trapped in a swift decline. Watch RSI against its downtrend line for clues here.
Nasdaq-100 (NDX) chart, 60-min
The 60-min chart shows the A-B-C bounce up close and I show where wave-C = wave-A at 2098.20, which is where price stopped today. As with the DOW and SPX I show the possibility for a slight pullback and then another new high to complete a 5-wave move up from Monday (c-waves are 5-wave moves) but too many times a small 4th and 5th wave are "hidden" and it's unreliable to count on it happening. That makes this a risky place for bulls and a good place to consider a short play. If it pulls back then use today's high as your stop. But then watch for a new high with negative divergences to set up the next shorting opportunity since it should at least pull back if not start a major decline. If it keeps heading higher, as shown in green, then look to buy the dips for a while.
Semiconductor Holders (SMH), Daily
The semis got a nice bounce today as well and almost made it up to its broken uptrend line from October 2002, currently near 33.25. That would be the first place I would look for failure (if it gets there) or else it could head to its broken neckline just above 34. The last low was met with a very bullish divergence on MACD after coming out of oversold so based on that signal I would expect a larger bounce, even if it pulled back first. So stay cautious about this one if shorting the semis, and keep an eye on it for bullish signals for the techs in general.
Russell-2000 (RUT) chart, Daily
The top of a parallel down-channel, based off the downtrend line along the lows of its decline, crosses its broken uptrend line from August 2004 near 776 so a slight pullback followed by another push higher could find resistance around that level. It was a strong bounce today but the RUT is clearly in a downtrend so any plays on the long side are still to be considered countertrend.
Russell-2000 (RUT) chart, 60-min
Once again, a slight pullback and then push higher (to the 776 area) would look best here but is not required. Based on this chart though, with no bearish divergences, I would think it's a risky play to consider a short play. I'd wait on this one to see if it follows the others if they start dropping back.
BIX banking index, Daily
The way I've got the decline from November 14th labeled the BIX can't rally above 289.85 without violating an EW rule that says wave-4 can't overlap wave-1 so based on this I'd say the banks are a short here against that level--makes for a very tight stop. This is also where the top of its parallel down-channel is currently located. If the banks can break above 290 then I'd look to buy the dips for now.
A look at the weekly chart keeps this year's steep drop in perspective in the larger pattern:
BIX banking index, Weekly
As I've pointed out before, the rising wedge pattern since the 2000 low is a bearish pattern and these typically get completely retraced. That would take the index back down to the 240 area if not the 2000 low near 211. The wave count for this year's drop is "squished" on this chart but shows the need for a stair-stepping lower into the new year.
Looking at the weekly chart of the brokers shows today's bounce brought price right up to its broken uptrend line from March 2003 through the May 2005 low (seems to be a common theme about today's rally). If it drops back down from today's high then it will look like a classic kiss goodbye and in fact is a short here until it proves it can rally further (needs a close above today's price).
Citigroup has been in the news a lot this week as it secured (expensive) funding from Abu Dhabi in an effort to continue to hide the true value of its mortgage-backed assets and other derivative mess. Instead of coming clean as HSBC did yesterday with their SIV holding, and get them onto their balance sheets, C continues to try to push their garbage under the carpet and hope no one notices the big lumps. Our banks have been shameful in their dealings with the public. As a shareholder I'd be outraged. But I'm not a shareholder so all I can do is mouth off about their despicable behavior. And with that I'll step down from my soapbox and discuss their chart since today's rally was supposedly about being relieved that the banks have seen the worst and it will get better from here (cough). Its chart says otherwise:
Citigroup (C), Daily
Like the banking index the wave count for this year's decline is not finished. It needs to stair-step lower in order to complete the count and my best guess is that we'll see C work its way down to below $20 (perhaps $15) into next year before it finds meaningful support. It could happen much faster than what I depict (for example it could finish well within the first quarter of 2008).
Citigroup has a different pattern than the BIX but the end result is the same--this monthly chart suggests further downside:
Citigroup (C), Monthly
The choppy price decline from its high in 2000 was followed by a corrective rally into the end of 2006. Notice the bearish divergence on MACD at the retest of the 2000 high. Two equal legs down for the A-B-C correction from 2000 would have it dropping to 22.35 but I'm thinking C will drop down to 15 before all is said and done, which will be back to its 1995 low.
U.S. Home Construction Index chart, DJUSHB, Daily
The home builder index continues to work its way lower towards its 215 Fib projection (and early 2001 low). It could drop lower but it's getting close now to where it could find a significant bottom. Shorts in these stocks should understand the risk is going to be shifting over to their side soon.
Oil chart, January contract (CL08F), Daily
Oil has broken its uptrend line from early October and could bounce back up for a retest of that trend line (shown in pink) which would have it rallying back up near 95 but it's just as likely to see it drop further to its next uptrend line and 50-dma near 87.
Oil Index chart, Daily
The oil stocks rallied with the broader market today but not as strongly and they're likely being influenced by the drop in the price of oil. If the rally can make it a little higher keep an eye on the downtrend line that's currently near 810 as the next leg down could be accompanied by some strong selling.
Transportation Index chart, TRAN, Daily
There's additional upside potential for the Transports to its downtrend line from July which coincides with its 50-dma near 4772. Not shown but if it can press a little higher than that then the broken uptrend line from March 2003, and its 200-dma, would be good upside targets. Otherwise a reversal in the broader market back down would likely have the Trannies following.
U.S. Dollar chart, Daily
The US dollar got a good bounce yesterday and was promptly slapped back down today. It broke above its downtrend line from October 22nd yesterday and then dropped back down below it today. The more important downtrend line is the one from August and is currently near 75.75. Until that trend line is broken the dollar could get another leg down in which case the Fib projections near 74.40 make for a good downside target to finally find a bottom.
Gold chart, December contract (GC07Z), Daily
With the US dollar probing for a bottom (I believe) it looks like gold already topped. After tagging a Fib projection at 845.37 in early November, where I suggested a short play on gold, the recent bounce should be a 2nd wave correction and the next move should be a strong decline that breaks the lower uptrend line near 786. A drop below 771 would confirm that we've seen the high for gold.
Results of today's economic reports and tomorrow's reports include the following:
Tomorrow's reports include the preliminary GDP report and new home sales, either of which could move the market if there's a nasty surprise. Otherwise Friday will be the more important day with some key reports that could influence the Fed for their December 11th meeting (or at least the market's reaction based on what it thinks the Fed will do with that data).
SPX chart, Weekly
The weekly chart has RSI hinting of a turn back up from oversold (but not MACD yet as it's more of a lagging indicator). I'll continue to show the possibility for a choppy rise higher into next year until the August low is taken out (which would negate the bullish wave count). The RUT may have provided us with a heads up in this regard--this week it broke the August low and therefore negated a bullish potential for a new high in that index. While we could always get a new high in the DOW and SPX without the RUT (which would be a bearish non-confirmation) I think it's unlikely that new highs are coming. But I'll keep it there as long as it's a possibility.
Today's rally was bullish and it has a lot of people looking for the rally to continue now for at least a few days if not a few weeks. The rally into the end of the year is something many expect. While the bearish sentiment has increased dramatically (bullish from a contrarian perspective) there are still a lot of people hoping for a year-end rally. Today's rally, especially off some strong support at this week's lows, will have many believing that rally has begun.
But we've seen too many of these bear market rallies suddenly fizzle and reverse sharply (part of the whippy stock market traders have been dealing with lately). So today's rally should be considered in that context. We need to see follow through, especially since we've got some significant resistance levels that were hit today. A pullback from today's high would be typical and if it consolidates in a sideways/down move (with overlapping highs and lows) then that would be a good signal that the rally will continue and bust up through resistance. However, if the pullback starts to become sharp with only small corrective bounces then I'd be looking to stay on the short side.
That leaves us looking to see what happens tomorrow, and maybe Friday, to help us figure out what's the next move for the market. Shorting it here should be a good move but keep your stop fairly tight. As I showed on the 60-min charts we could get a relatively quick pullback and then a new minor high which would be the next opportunity to short it to see what kind of pullback/decline develops. It's risky when you consider the fact that you're stepping in front of a strong rally but catching turns in the market is always faced with that risk.
The more conservative thing to do here is let the market tell us what's next. If
we get a sharp decline then short the bounce. If we see a continuation of a
strong rally, through resistance, then buy the pullbacks. Be satisfied with
taking small chunks out of the middle and stay disciplined. The volatility is a
killer if you don't manage your risk properly. Good luck.
Play Editor's Note: The two-day rally in the market is very impressive and we would be willing to consider some bullish plays even though the major indices are still in bearish channels. However, we do not want to chase a 540+ point move in the DJIA or a 4.8% rally in the NASDAQ Composite. Wait and watch for the dip before considering new positions. FYI: There are plenty of market pundits that believe this to just an extended oversold bounce inside the current bearish trend.
Constellation Energy - CEG - cls: 98.16 chg: -0.26 stop: 94.45
Warning flag should be waving in your head if you're bullish on CEG. The stock has completely ignored a very impressive two-day rally in the markets. In spite of this relative weakness CEG's pattern is still bullish. However, what is not bullish is the above average volume over the last three days with the stock going sideways. We noted it yesterday. This smells like distribution. More nimble traders may want to open bullish positions here with a tight stop under today's low or under $96.00. We would suggest readers wait for a rally above $100 or 101 before initiating new positions. If you're feeling conservative then readers might want to raise their stop loss toward $96.00. The trend remains bullish. Our target is the $107.50-110.00 range.
Picked on November 20 at $100.56
Energizer - ENR - close: 109.93 chg: +0.25 stop: 104.99
ENR is another stock that should be sending off warning flares if you're bullish. Shares of ENR have ignored the market's big two-day rally (or short squeeze if you prefer). It's like traders are ignoring what was strong during the market's sell-off and focusing on stocks that have been beaten down (a.k.a. bargain shopping). The overall pattern for ENR remains bullish and we would still consider new positions here but a rally above today's high ($110.30) or above the $112.50 level would be much more encouraging. More conservative traders may want to use a tighter stop loss near the 100-dma (around 107.70). Our target is the $119.00-120.00 range. The P&F chart points to a $157 target.
Picked on November 26 at $112.75 *triggered
Express Scripts - ESRX - close: 68.14 chg: +2.45 stop: 62.45
Now this is more like it! ESRX jumped higher with a 3.7% gain. The stock has broken out above resistance near $66.00 and closed at new highs. Our target is the $69.50-70.00 range. More aggressive traders may want to aim higher. The Point & Figure chart suggests a $97 target.
Picked on November 13 at $ 64.67
Flowserve - FLS - cls: 93.41 change: +3.53 stop: 88.45
Our play in FLS has turned positive again. The stock rallied to a 3.9% gain albeit on below average volume. This looks like a new entry point to buy calls although more conservative traders may want to wait for a rally over $95.00. Our target is the $99.50-100.00 range. The P&F chart has a $108 target.
Picked on November 25 at $ 93.04
Gilead Sciences - GILD - cls: 45.83 change: +1.34 stop: 41.74
It looks like the BTK biotech index is breaking out from a bearish channel. Helping lead the charge higher is GILD, which rose over 3% today. The move over short-term resistance near $45.00 is definitely a positive for GILD. Our target is the $47.00-48.00 range. More aggressive traders may want to aim higher.
Picked on November 13 at $ 43.11
Synaptics Inc. - SYNA - close: 60.35 chg: +3.77 stop: 52.95*new*
The market's big rally and strength in tech stocks helped lift SYNA to a 6.6% gain. The stock actually cleared potential round-number resistance at $60.00. Shares could hit our target in the $61.50-62.00 range tomorrow. We are raising our stop loss to $52.95. More conservative traders may want to use a tighter stop or just lock in profits now.
Picked on November 26 at $ 56.55 *triggered
ExxonMobil - XOM - close: 87.92 chg: +1.54 stop: 82.99
Oil has crashed in the last couple of sessions. Crude oil futures have fallen about $7 toward the $90 level. Yet shares of XOM have been bouncing. The widespread market rally lifted XOM to a 1.78% gain. We would still be buyers here but XOM is nearing resistance near $89 and its 100-dma. More conservative traders might want to adjust their stops toward $84.00. We are leaving our stop under the 200-dma. Our target is the $92.50-95.00 range. More conservative traders may want to lock in some gains near $90.00. More aggressive traders might want to narrow their exit range to the $94-95 zone.
Picked on November 13 at $ 86.75
ESSEX Property - ESS - cls: 101.57 chg: +1.32 stop: 105.55
ESS under performed the broader markets but shares still managed a 1.3% bounce. The rally ran into trouble near its descending 10-dma. The pattern is still bearish but we would hesitate to open new put positions given the bounce in the markets this week. Our target is support in the $94.00-93.00 range. The P&F chart is much more bearish with a $78 target.
Picked on November 20 at $101.75
Harley Davidson - HOG - cls: 48.02 change: +1.54 stop: 50.01
It is hard to ignore a 331-point gain in the DJIA or a 2.8% rally in the S&P 500. Shorts covered and HOG added 3.3% but shares remain near short-term resistance at $48.00 and under its 50-dma. Maybe tomorrow, when the rally euphoria wears off, investors will note that Standard & Poor's downgraded their credit rating on HOG due to slowing sales. We would wait for the bounce to stumble before jumping in with put positions. Overall we do not see any changes from our comments on Tuesday. Our target is the $41.00-40.00 range. The P&F chart is bearish with a $38 target.
Picked on November 27 at $ 46.48
Celgene - CELG - close: 63.76 change: +1.42 stop: 63.01
It looks like the BTK biotech index is breaking out higher from a bearish channel. Considering the short-term reversal in the markets we're dropping CELG as a bearish candidate. We had been waiting for a breakdown under support at $60.00 but it has not yet occurred. Our suggested trigger was $59.90.
Picked on November xx at $ xx.xx <-- see TRIGGER
Canadian Pacific - CP - cls: 65.63 change: +2.10 stop: 65.26
The oversold bounce (and short covering) in CP took another chunk out of CP's recent declines. The stock rallied 3.3% and broke out over round-number resistance at the $65.00 level. Shares actually traded over technical resistance at the 200-dma, probably hitting even more stops. Our stop loss was at $65.26 so the play has been closed.
Picked on November 19 at $ 62.85
J.B.Hunt - JBHT - close: 26.03 change: +1.51 stop: 26.11
A two-day crash in crude oil futures finally gave the transports something to rally about. Trucking stock JBHT soared over 6% (yup - short covering again) and hit our stop loss at $26.11 this afternoon. The overall trend in JBHT is still bearish and concerns about a slowing economy and a slow fourth quarter are not going to go away overnight.
Picked on November 20 at $ 24.95
PACCAR - PCAR - close: 50.62 change: +2.50 stop: 50.26
The market rally (and short covering) pushed PCAR to a 5.19% gain. Shares cleared resistance at the 50.00 level and hit our stop loss at $50.26. The larger trend is still bearish but short-term PCAR may have put in a bottom.
Picked on November 16 at $ 46.99 *triggered
There are 3 indicators in ADDITION to price action and patterns (e.g., double bottoms, etc.) that I've used since before the '87 crash, to identify significant bottoms in the market. One of these 3 simple ('little') indicators doesn't work for tops; tops are hard enough to pinpoint, at least in bull market trends, so you have to work extra hard to time tops. More on my three indicators after a little digression on market timing to begin with! Thanks to Michael Lewis (author of Liar's Poker, the book and many fine market-related articles).
Many market participants, money managers and analysts don't believe that you can "time" the market anyway. The efficient market theory holds that because the news (impacting the market) is random and the market reacts or adjusts so quickly to it, that you had best buy sector or index funds rather than try to 'beat' the market by your own trading or by hiring a Wall Street gunslinger (money manager).
Today for example: I know that many, if not most market watchers will assume that it was talk from a Fed official that triggered this market turnaround and ostensibly that was the 'reason'. However, the market gave signs days before this 'news' came out that an upside reversal was coming. All this upside reversal needed was a 'TRIGGER' and you could have been in calls BEFORE that triggering event/news.
A RANDOM WALK DOWN WALL STREET:
In the early 1960s, the efficient-markets hypothesis finally took off, thanks first to Paul Samuelson, who reminded everyone of Bacheliers paper, and then to Eugene Fama, who tested it against actual U.S. market data. Fama discovered that the Frenchman had got it exactly right back in 1900: A person could learn no useful information about future stock market prices by examining past performance. Chart reading, graph plotting, momentum analysis, and all the rest of the more esoteric Wall Street techniques for predicting stock-price movements were hokum. Fama went further: No public information at all is of any use to a trader trying to beat the market. Balance-sheet analysis, industry insight, articles in the Wall Street Journal, a feel for the character of a C.E.O.; these are all a complete waste of the investors time, as whats already known is factored into stock prices too quickly to act on it, and what isnt known is inherently unpredictable.
"The true news is random," says Burton Malkiel, a Wall Street banker turned Princeton professor, who published the most famous book on the efficient-markets hypothesis, "A Random Walk Down Wall Street". Burton said that..."That's what people had trouble grasping. It's not that stock prices are capricious. It's that the news is capricious."
The random walk/efficient markets theorists do admit that there are superior stock pickers, who over the long haul, can outperform or way outperform the market averages; e.g., Warren Buffet. Then there are people like Peter Lynch, who had a stellar record managing his Magellan fund, although his hand-picked successor could not outperform the benchmark S&P. Then there is the world of great traders who have made tons of money for decades; some of these guys (I don't know any women, although there must be some) are private investors/speculators and they don't and will never have a 'public' record. They are not the types that seek public recognition, only to beat the market and make money consistently. This group seems to contradict the above statements, but no doubt the true random-walk believers would have a rebuttal to what I'M saying.
I would agree that great traders and investors are like world-class athletes in that there are VERY few of them. This doesn't mean that a good number of speculators can't make money IF they have effective methods and discipline. Some will time or try to time the market, some will do other creative things that involve a good notion of what range a stock or index is likely to trade in order to collect or pocket premium, and so on. My interest is in predicting or timing the 2-3 day to 2-3 week price swings and I tend to write mostly about how one can use technical inputs to do that. No doubt, a person is happiest who sticks to his/her passion and areas of past success.
3 BOTTOM INDICATORS THAT WORK IN TANDEM:
#1: BOTTOMS (AND TOPS) TEND TO OCCUR AFTER BEARISH (OR BULLISH) EXTREMES IN
When #1 is joined by the #2 indicator, evidence grows that the market is setting up for an upside reversal.
#2: BOTTOMS TEND TO COME AFTER CERTAIN 'OVERSOLD' EXTREMES:
When my #3 indicator joins #1 and #2 indicators, the evidence is coming in strongly to get ready for a big rebound.
When 1,2 and 3 indicators are in synch, I tend to view this as a trade I can go in 'heavier' on, although still within the bounds of money management rules; e.g., not committing 100 percent of my account on one trade. Moreover, the use of effective stops is always my advice. (In a recent Index Trader column I recommended buying DJX January calls (slightly out of the money is my preference) if the Dow traded down to the 12,800 area which it did (twice) and with a stop/exit point on the trade at 12750 in INDU. The intraday low of day before yesterday in the Dow was 12743. Today's close: 13289! My stop would have 'worked' on a CLOSE-only basis and I only lightened up some at my exit point. I don't regret having a somewhat lesser profit today, as today's close could have been 12289; unlikely, but I adhere to risk points rather than risk letting a loss run. I also try to buy at extremes, so I can work with tighter stops and have a sizable risk to reward potential.)
#3: BOTTOMS FOLLOW KEY CONTRACTIONS/UPTURNS IN NASDAQ AND NYSE UP VOLUMES
This indicator is a CONTRARIAN indicator: when many or most are bullish, be wary
of a top; when many or most are bearish, look for a bottom.
A top could come on the SAME day as the indicator, which happened in fact in late-October. After the early-October bullish extreme reading at the red down arrow (CPRATIO line registered at or above the 'overbought', extreme bullishness level), the top came 5 days later. The same for the last reading at or below the 'oversold', extreme bearishness as noted at the green up arrow: the bottom came exactly 5 trading days later.
What I start to look for after signs that traders have gotten to key extremes in bullishness or bearishness ('too much' or unrealistic for how far a move can/will go before a reaction sets in), I then want to pay attention to where the major indexes are in terms of the 13-day RSI (Relative Strength Index), which is another way to measure 'overbought' or 'oversold' levels in terms of how far a move has carried without a significant counter-trend move.
Indicator # 2
One problem or perceived problem with this Indicator is that an index or stock can and will hit oversold (or overbought) extremes multiple times. This isn't a big obstacle if you are using tandem indicators. The question here is, was the S&P 500 (SPX) shown below, hitting an oversold level in the same time frame as an extreme in bearish sentiment. Absolutely, it was just the 3rd time! Moreover, SPX was declining on rising 'relative strength' so to speak, as highlighted by the DIVERGING trendlines: one following prices lower in the last 7-10 trading sessions, one showing RSI lows that were on a rising trend. This is a classic bullish price/RSI divergence pattern.
As is most often the case, we can look to the STRONGEST index in the current market cycle to best gauge where the overall market may be bottoming in terms of momentum indicators like the Relative Strength Index (RSI) indicator. A very telling story was provided by the action of the Nasdaq 100 (NDX) index in terms of the 13-day RSI. There was a SINGLE 1-day extreme in the area that I find defines 'oversold' (between 30-33) and this was followed by 'basing' action thereafter as prices went sideways, showing good buying interest on dips around and under the 2000 level.
If you took the basing action as what it was, as something likely to precede a good-sized rally especially given what was showing with indicators #1 and 2, you got positioned in NDX calls BEFORE the sharp jump higher when premiums expanded like gangbusters; when the sellers immediately jacked up the premiums by so much it will take a big further move higher just to break even!
Last but not least is:
Again, Nasdaq being the key mover of late, its 10-day moving average of daily exchange advancing (UP) volume made its volume indicator the key one in terms of my last key market timing indicator. The contraction of the 10-day up volume average to below the 300-500 million share zone happened recently (see below), for the second time since August, and was followed by an upturn yesterday that PRECEDED today's big rally. This turn up made this the last of my 3 key indicators to get in synch and was consistent with the potential S&P double bottoms and the basing in NDX around 2000. All of these things said GO.
The NYSE 10-day up volume figures seen below were less straight-forward in their predictive value than the Nasdaq, but this market also formed a picture perfect double bottom. The key here from study of my last chart and its comments is that the 10-day Up volume average was rising and prices finally were bound to follow suit. The key final 'timing' aspect were all the other indicator and price patterns. Volume preceded price as they say. The S&P stocks bottomed in terms of buying interest (i.e., volume patterns), but prices took some time to follow suit.
Today's Newsletter Notes: Market Wrap by Keene H. Little, Trader's Corner by
Leigh Stevens, and all other plays and content by the Option Investor staff.
Option Investor Inc is neither a registered Investment Advisor nor a Broker/Dealer. Readers are advised that all information is issued solely for informational purposes and is not to be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy, nor is it to be construed as a recommendation to buy, hold or sell (short or otherwise) any security. All opinions, analyses and information included herein are based on sources believed to be reliable and written in good faith, but no representation or warranty of any kind, expressed or implied, is made including but not limited to any representation or warranty concerning accuracy, completeness, correctness, timeliness or appropriateness. In addition, we do not necessarily update such opinions, analysis or information. Owners, employees and writers may have long or short positions in the securities that are discussed.
Readers are urged to consult with their own independent financial advisors with respect to any investment. All information contained in this report and website should be independently verified.
To ensure you continue to receive email from Option Investor please add "email@example.com"
Option Investor Inc