The markets were down sharply after a string of earnings misses. Today was all about revenue, earnings and guidance.
Yesterday good news from Yahoo! helped the major indexes to snap back from early morning weakness and regain last weeks close. Today, poor reports have sent the markets back down, breaking an important support line and raising the question of just how far down are we going to go?
Futures were down sharply this morning following high profile revenue misses from Dupont, Xerox and 3M. The S&P futures trade was down as much as -16 points for most of the morning with the Dow and Nasdaq posting similar declines.
We have been expecting earnings to be bad for some time. Estimates have been ratcheting down for the last two quarters as the world slowdown reached what many believe now to be a short term bottom. Now we're here and it's not the current earnings and it's not the revenue short-falls that are hurting us, its the guidance. Major world players have been lowering their full-year and fourth quarter guidance and that is what is depressing stock prices. Investors are worrying over the outlook for fourth quarter profits, but is the worry misplaced?
Year-to-date the major indexes are up. The S&P is (or was two days ago) up over 15% with the Dow and Nasdaq close behind. The Dow was up close to 10% before Friday's open; more than half of the Dow stocks were up more than 10%. The three day sell off which started on Friday has brought the S&P down to about a 10% gain on the year, 6% for the Dow. Compared to last year's markets gains even this still looks good. It's no surprise that many investors and portfolio managers are choosing to take profits.
One trend I have noticed amongst earnings reports this quarter is this: Revenues are falling short but profits are in-line or above expectations, basically this means that margins are improving for one reason or another. If this trend of increased profit on lower revenue continues into the fourth quarter, and we get the fourth quarter rise in US and world GDP then corporate profits should also improve and possibly surpass the current guidance. Lowered guidance and the chances of increased profits is a recipe for upside surprises and market rallies. However, the strength of the bounce, if any, will be heavily dependent on economic data.
Today also starts FedWatch as the FOMC begins their October meeting. The committee is not expected to make any changes to policy but the statements will be very important. Every word of the statement will be carefully scrutinized for what it says now and what any changes may mean. The Fed could easily spark buying or selling, depending on their outlook.
This quarter the economic conditions are showing signs of improving; housing has apparently turned a corner and unemployment is down at the lowest levels since the start of the crisis. The signs are pointing to a stronger third quarter than expected despite the revenue shortfalls we keep running into. The economic data, which supports earlier predictions of a fourth quarter economic uptick, has caused many to speculate that the 3rd quarter is actually an earnings trough and that the 4th quarter will show an improvement. If this is the case then the fear could be misplaced. Tomorrow look to the Fed for confirmation or denial of my theory.
Europe and Asia
The European markets closed down more than 1% today. Earnings worries here and in the Eurozone are weighing heavily on share prices. Adding to the turmoil is yet another development in the Spanish bail-out-or-not drama. The country, or at least parts of it, were downgraded by Moody's based on budgetary short falls and liquidity issues. These problems won't be helped by a downgrade, which will likely spook some Spanish bond holders. I have said in past recaps that the appearance of EU and Spanish leaders working on the problem may be enough to keep confidence up but at some point enough has to be enough.
Asian shares ended the day mixed. Earnings caution helped to keep prices in check while investors sift through the data. Some headline stories out of the east today include Taiwan's inflation is up, Japan is contemplating more QE, China real estate lending rebounded in the third quarter and South Korea is expected to have grown at the rate of 1.8% for 2012.
Gold and Oil
Gold traded lower today, extending its decline to near a two month low. The price of gold doesn't care about corporate earnings, it cares about the economy and the price of money. With economic data supporting stabilization in the short term there is little hope for more QE. Without the hope of additional money in the system and a growing fear of weakening global demand (due to lower corporate guidance and business outlook) the price of gold should continue to fall toward support. The FOMC statement tomorrow could impact trading and add some volatility in the short term.
The Gold Index has continued to trade sideways; the potential bull triangle has failed. Today the index traded down in tandem with the underlying metal as lower prices impacted future profit expectations. The index dropped down below its short term moving average and is now approaching its long term support level of 200. This level has been an important pivot point over the last 5 years, if the index falls below this level new down sides targets of 275 and 250 will come into play. Barrick Gold, one barometer of the gold industry, is scheduled to report earnings November 1st. The report should give us insight into supply/demand and price expectations for the fourth quarter and into 2013.
The Gold Index, daily
Weak corporate guidance and revenues are also impacting the price of oil. The reductions in guidance are causing speculators to lower expectations for demand and subsequently prices. The good news is that the lower prices are good for the economy and corporations and could help with the fourth quarter up tick I have been talking about. The price of oil fell today by another -2.6% on global slowdown worries, continuing its slide below $90.
The Oil Index gapped down today, dropping below the 30 day EMA, the 150 day EMA and long term support. The index has been moving down from the top of a range and is looking like it will keep moving down in the near term. Downside targets for the index are 1150 and an intersection with the up trend line around 1100.
The Oil Index, daily
Bond rates fell today on the ten year treasury. The rates are still above the long term support and the short term moving average. The ten year also seems to be catching the added boost of longer term bearish traders. The rate has climbed above the 150 day EMA and could be getting ready to make a move higher. This makes me ask the question â€œIf bond rates are falling and investors are leaving the safe haven of US backed debt where are they going...into equities?'
Ten Year Treasury Yield, daily
Earnings, Earnings, Earnings
Dupont spooked the markets this morning when it reported an 11% drop in revenue for the fiscal third quarter. The company also announced that it would be cutting 1,500 jobs in a restructuring effort and that it is lowering its full year outlook for 2012 by nearly a dollar per share. Previous guidance had full year earnings in a range around $4.20, now Dupont is expecting to earn a mere $3.30 per share. The stock dropped close to 9% today on high volume to a long term support level.
Xerox also fell by nearly 9% today. The company reported adjusted earnings in-line with estimates on lower revenues. It was the lower revenues that investors focused on. The thing for us to take note of though is that Xerox is one more business to improve margins over the last year. This is a trend that is echoing throughout the business world and will help stocks increase profits and beat estimates at some point in the future. Xerox fell on heavy volume to a one year low but was halted at the long term support line. MACD and Stochastic indicators both support the possibility of a bottom at this level but it will take a little more time to confirm that hypothesis.
3M Corporation could be the poster child for the current market. The company increased earnings on slightly lower revenue and guided the full year to just below the previous range. The new guidance is in line with analysts estimates and according to the press release â€œreflects the current economic realitiesâ€. In a nutshell they said that they sold a little less due to the economic slowness, earned a little more profits due to better margins and that the future was more or less OK but recent global weakness still gives them reason for concern. The stock dropped on the news, losing close to 4% on only average volume. The fall took the stock below a long term support level and the 150 day EMA.
One of few bright spots in the market today was Harley Davidson. The company reported earnings in line with its expectations, reiterated its previous guidance and announced that it expects to spend less than anticipated on restructuring this year. Investors met the news with enthusiasm and sent the stock up by more than 7%. The move took share price above the short and long term moving averages and a short term resistance level.
Harley Davidson, daily
Coach was another surprising earnings beat on a day dominated by earnings fears. The company beat on the top and bottom lines and is standing by its full year guidance. The company increased earnings and revenue over the same time last year by more than 5% each and says it is well positioned going into the holiday season. The stock, which has been trading near a 12 month low popped on the news, gaining 8% on increased volume. The stock is currently trapped between the long and short term EMA's. A break above the 150 day EMA is necessary for me to take a bullish technical outlook.
Facebook reported after the bell. The highly anticipated report was expected to show a reversal of last quarters -$0.08 loss. The social media behemoth surprised investors and even beat the streets estimates. Facebook posted earnings of $0.12 per share versus the estimated $0.11 and the stock gained close to 10%.
The markets opened broadly lower this morning, all three posting double digit declines in the opening minutes of trading. The S&P started the day with a -9 point move that quickly slid to -12, -15 and lower before reaching today's bottom around 1408. This move has taken the S&P into the very important support zone that we all have been watching for the last few months. The index must hold this level to remain bullish into the near term. A drop below this could spark technical selling and bring us down to next support at 1380 and then 1350.
The daily charts look a little ominous. Today's selling has completed a bear move that is nearly identical to the bullish continuation signal we got only a few weeks ago. The selling, though severe in comparison to the last few months, is a natural part of market cycles and has not broken the longer term trends. The S&P has been making gains all year in the face of slowing corporate earnings and economic growth, a pause is natural and good for the rally's health. The markets could take a breather and blow off some more earnings steam over the next week to ten days as the next round of economic data comes out.
Looking at the short term charts, 30 minutes bars, we can see that the selling began last week as the S&P approached the four year closing highs. In fact, over the last 5 weeks the index has done the same thing three times, making successively lower highs each time. This suggests the bears are getting more aggressive; they're willing to sell at a lower price each time the S&P reaches a peak. The momentum on this most recent down streak reached an extreme on Friday and then diverged from price yesterday and today. The difference is that yesterday we got a good report from Yahoo which helped to drive the price back up above support. If the S&P does not regain this support level over the next day or two more selling could ensue.
SPX, 30 minute bars
The VIX finally made a spike up from the long term lows. The spike took the VIX above the short term moving average but failed to cross the critical 20 level into the â€œfearfulâ€ zone. The index is still well within the safe range of 15-20 and looks like it will stay there. Today's candle and upper wick suggest that options traders were selling as prices were rising. This could mean that some of the options protection is coming out of the markets as investors and traders sell protective puts and buy-back short calls. If this is the case it will reduce resistance in the S&P going forward. Until the VIX actually crosses into the +20 range I have to remain neutral to bullish on the markets in the near to short terms.
The VIX, daily
Earnings will continue to add volatility to the markets. This week is one of the busiest for the earnings season with over 500 companies reporting. Competing for attention will be the FOMC statements and new economic data. I believe it will be the data that drives direction and not 3rd quarter earnings. The data supports a stabilization from the the 3rd quarter lows and an increasing possibility for corporate earnings to improve in the fourth. The S&P could trend sideways for the next 4-6 weeks as we wait for more data to point the way or it could drop down to the long term trend before making up its mind about which way to go.
We are definitely in a time of uncertainty. The third quarter was poor, revenue is down, profits are up, data is stabilizing and guidance is being reduced. With so much conflicting information it is easy to understand why the markets are trying to sell off. I expect more volatility overnight as the world markets react to a new round of Flash PMI reports. Later in the day statements from the FOMC could help us understand where the economy is going and on Friday the GDP advance numbers will help us understand where we have been.
Stay vigilant, be conservative and remember the trend.