NEW DIRECTIONAL PUT PLAYS
Cummins Inc. - CMI - close: 97.90 change: -1.23
Stop Loss: 101.55
Target(s): To Be Determined
Current Option Gain/Loss: Unopened
Average Daily Volume = 2.0 million
Entry on November -- at $---.--
Listed on November 17, 2015
Time Frame: Exit PRIOR to January option expiration
New Positions: Yes, see below
Shares of CMI are in a bear market. The current down trend shows no signs of slowing. The stock is down -32% year to date.
CMI is in the industrial goods sector. According to the company,
"Cummins Inc., a global power leader, is a corporation of complementary business units that design, manufacture, distribute and service diesel and natural gas engines and related technologies, including fuel systems, controls, air handling, filtration, emission solutions and electrical power generation systems. Headquartered in Columbus, Indiana, (USA) Cummins currently employs approximately 54,600 people worldwide and serves customers in approximately 190 countries and territories through a network of approximately 600 company-owned and independent distributor locations and approximately 7,200 dealer locations. Cummins earned $1.65 billion on sales of $19.2 billion in 2014."
CMI reported its Q2 results on July 28th. The company beat estimates on both the top and bottom line. Yet the post-earnings rally quickly faded. Shares were already in a down trend and investors used the rally to sell.
Unfortunately, the earnings picture has taken a dramatic turn for the worse.
Business conditions deteriorated in the third quarter. Wall Street was expecting CMI to report earnings of $2.59 a share on revenues of $4.92 billion. The company delivered earnings of $2.14 a share. Revenues fell -5.5% to $4.62 billion. Management lowered their 2015 guidance and said they would start laying off up to 2,000 people.
The stock crashed to new multi-year lows the next day (see chart).
A bearish note from Morgan Stanley didn't help either. A team of analysts at Morgan Stanley cut their rating on CMI to a "sell" and slashed their price target down to $79.
Here is an excerpt from the Morgan Stanley note:
We believe CMI is facing three major headwinds that will drive share price underperformance: 1) The secular growth story within the Components business is dissipating - as developed markets shift regulatory focus from emissions to fuel economy, we expect CMI's Emissions Solutions revenue growth to converge with production; this represents a $0.35 EPS headwind. 2) The NAFTA Engine business is likely to suffer from market share erosion - as per our analysis on pages 4-6, we calculate $0.40-0.60 EPS risk associated with incremental Ford, Freightliner, and PACCAR vertical integration. 3) Consensus forecasts do not yet reflect the full impact of a NAFTA truck industry downturn - based on ACT's outlook, we see $0.40-0.65 EPS risk associated with cyclical decline in the NA truck market. While the negative reaction to today's 3Q miss and 2015e guide-down implies increasing awareness of cyclical risk, our bearish call focuses more on the impediments to secular growth and market share. (source)
A couple of weeks later, on November 10th, CMI held their analyst day. The Board of Directors approved another $1 billion stock buyback program to replace the previous $1 billion buyback they announced in July 2014. This news didn't help the stock. That is probably because CMI warned that they expect 2016 revenues to be -5% below 2015 (or worse).
I will point out that some investors see CMI as a dividend trade. The stock's decline has boosted the dividend yield on CMI's stock to nearly 4%. We should keep in mind that if the Fed starts raising rates it will put pressure on high-dividend names. Speaking of dividends, shares of CMI should begin trading ex-dividend on November 18th or 20th (I saw two different dates). The quarterly dividend is 97.5 cents a share.
The last few days have seen CMI breakdown below round-number, psychological resistance at the $100.00 level. The oversold bounce has failed to lift CMI back above this key level. We think CMI accelerates lower from here. Last Friday's low was $97.41. Tonight we are suggesting a trigger to buy puts at $97.30.
Trigger @ $97.30
- Suggested Positions -
Buy the 2016 JAN $95 PUT (CMI160115P95) current ask $3.60
option price is a current quote and not a suggested entry price.
Entry disclaimer: To avoid an unfavorable entry point, we will not launch a new play if the stock gaps open more than $1.00 past our suggested entry point.
Option Format: symbol-year-month-day-call-strike